The saga starts above the Wall as three men of the nights watch are ambushed by supernatural creatures. These scenes are perfect, the mood is dark and frightening. We also get our first view of the Wall which lives up to my expectations.
Then we come to the opening credits, and they are fucking awesome. The camera descends on a map of Westeros that comes to life before ours eyes as the major locales are animated like pieces of the worlds most elaborate clock. Best of all the intro will change from episode to episode depending on where the action is taking place that week.
We first meet the Stark family in Winterfell, this scene is not from the books. It does a reasonably good job of introducing the members of the family. Maisie Williams is strong as the Tomboy Arya. We also get our first "Winter is Coming" reference. I like Michelle Fairley as Catelyn but my wife mentioned that she seems too old for Ned and I have read the same on various message boards.
Next, we come to the beheading of Will from the nights watch. Good scene but I have seen it thirty times over the past few months so it didn't have much of an emotional impact. Isaac Hempstead-Wright is really good as Bran, this is a bit more challenging then your typical child actor fare.
The direwolf scene is first time I had a problem with the pilot. I can't describe the feeling other then what I saw in my head when reading the books was a lot cooler then what I saw on the show. Perhaps its because they are all standing around a giant direwolf prop that makes it feel a bit cheesy. I suppose that is one of the challenges of bringing an epic fantasy book to a visual format. The writing is a bit stiff here as well and I didn't love the long awkward pauses. As far as departures from the book are concerned, Theon Greyjoy is written a bit differently but he still comes off as a prick so that's good.
Are the direwolves going to work in general? I don't know. These dogs should work for season one but what happens when they are supposed to be 300 lbs and ripping knights off of horses. Can we get James Cameron involved? Is their anything worse then TV budget CGI?
Next, we have a gorgeous shot of Kings Landing, our first shot of the iron throne and the introduction of the Lannister twins. This scene is not from the book, and I am a bit concerned about how the Lannisters are portrayed at this point in the narrative. In the first book they are clear villains, but over the course of the series they become more sympathetic. However, on the show I worry that the producers are going to try and establish an opaque morality early on, which may cause newbies to ask "who am I rooting for again?".
Lena Headey is not pretty enough to Cersei, but she plays the role admirably. Nickolaj Coster-Waldau (NCW from now on)is great as Jaime and I look forward to seeing his story progress.
The action returns to Winterfell and we see Ned polishing Ice under the weirwood. The imagery here is lush and matches up with this well known painting.
After a few quick scenes depicting the preparations for King Roberts arrival, we see young Bran climbing the walls of Winterfell. Here is a good rule of thumb for all you aspiring showrunners, if something looks like it was filmed in front of a green screen it is crap and you shouldn't use it.
King Robert makes his entrance at Winterfell and I have to say I was pleasantly surprised with Mark Addy's performance. All I really know him from is the Full Monty and I was worried he would make Robert into a buffoon but he has enough gravitas. The scene also included an really annoying voice over conversation between Sansa and Arya identifying Jaime Lannister. I hated this, it was forced exposition and it was really clunky. I am hoping that after a few episodes we don't have to do this sort of thing and we can just tell the story.
The next scene in the crypts was one of my favorites of the episode. We get to see the bond between Ned and Robert and while the conversation informs it is still rather entertaining. "You remember me at 16? All I wanted to do was crack skulls and fuck girls." Not from the books but it should have been.
I don't think Winterfell actually has whore houses but that departure from canon is acceptable in servicing the introduction of the great Tyrion Lannister. Peter Dinklage is going to devour this role, and I can already tell he is going to have all the best lines.
The story shifts across the Narrow Sea to Pentos where we are introduced to the Targaryens, Daenerys and Viserys. Harry Lloyd as Viserys is a total creep, which is what he is supposed to be. In this episode Emilia Clarke isn't asked to do much but stare into the distance so I will have to see how she does as the story progresses.
The scenes in Pentos are the weakest in the pilot. The writing is stiff and lacks humanity. Roger Allam is serviceable as the merchant Illyrio but writing doesn't offer him much to work with.
Back in Winterfell, Sansa still sucks..."please, please its the only thing I ever wanted." ugh
I loved Joseph Mawle as Benjen Stark, his scenes with Jon Snow and Ned at the feast are really strong. Speaking of Jon Snow, his scene with Tyrion was fantastic and I look forward to see their interaction the next few episodes.
I hated the Dothraki wedding. Again the Pentos scenes have stifling dialogue and I don't like how the Dothraki are portrayed as generic brown people. In the books the Dothraki horde are based on the Mongols, here they just look like savages. Jason Momoa as Khal Drogo looks good, but the dothraki as a whole don't feel right. The sex, nudity, and violence at the wedding is right from the books but its one of those things that reads better then it looks. Jorah Mormont is far too good looking but he has a nice presence although he is awkwardly introduced at the wedding.
The consumation scene is not faithful to the books and takes on a bit of a rapey feel, although I am not nearly as upset about this as some commentators.
Finally, we see Bran climbing up the old tower of Winterfell to discover the queen and her twin brother fucking. A couple things with this scene. First of all did we need more doggy style? I have always imagined Jaime and Cersei to be standing with Jaime fucking her up against a wall with his back to Bran, Cersei opens her eyes and screams...The other I have with this scene is the amount of time it seems to take. In my mind the the push and the "What I do for love line" is delivered impulsively by Jaime. A quick decision by a man who has survived by being brash. Here it seems to linger and last forever.
Final thoughts:
I enjoyed this viewing more then any others. I don't know exactly why. Perhaps I am starting to rationalize the things that I don't like?
The Good: The visuals are fantastic, if a bit too airbrushed at times. The atmosphere in general was a real strong point, particularly at Winterfell and beyond the wall. One early thought, scenes outdoors during the day seemed a bit artificial.The opening credits are so much fun to watch, and I have watched them about a dozen times.The acting is really top notch Sean Bean as Ned of course, all the children are really strong as well the actors overcame some writing that was heavy on the pronouns. Say Robert Baratheon five times fast.
The Bad: Too much clunky exposition, I expected this but it still was a little bit much. I worry that this is going to turn off people who just want to get into the story. Hopefully by episode four it really starts to get cooking.
The Ugly: I am worried about overt fantasy elements being cheesy. I mentioned the direwolves earlier but lets just say they are the least problematic of the fantistical creatures that show up. When the overt fantasy takes place it really doesn't play well on TV. Lets be honesty fantasy is a little cheesy. But in the minds eye you can gloss over the more ridiculous aspects of it, but when you see it on the screen their is nowhere to hide.
No comments:
Post a Comment